Malta's Bill 55, the controversial 2023 legislation that bars recognition and enforcement of foreign court judgements arising from claims on foreign soil, continues to operate in legal uncertainty after the European Court of Justice (ECJ) declined to rule on its EU law compatibility this week.
The ECJ's decision to dismiss a referral on procedural grounds disappointed those seeking clarity on whether the law violates EU member state obligations to recognize cross-border judgements. The case that prompted the referral originated from Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder that had secured judgements from Austrian courts for players seeking gambling-loss refunds from Maltese-licensed operators offering services without local licences. When Malta refused recognition of the Austrian judgement, the Austrian court referred the matter to the ECJ. However, the ECJ ruled the referral inadmissible, determining that the underlying dispute between Spielerschutz Sigma and its legal adviser constituted a legal malpractice claim rather than a genuine EU law question requiring judicial interpretation.
Legal experts confirm the ECJ's procedural dismissal was unsurprising. Felix Hohenthanner, an Austrian lawyer, noted that the case lacked sufficient procedural requisites for ECJ intervention, while Terence Cassar of Maltese firm GTG characterized the underlying dispute as essentially a legal malpractice lawsuit with little connection to Bill 55's substantive compatibility questions.
The practical consequence is significant: Austrian players seeking refunds from Maltese-licensed operators continue facing substantial barriers to recovery, particularly absent other identifiable operator assets within European jurisdiction. The lack of an ECJ ruling on Bill 55's merits leaves the law's EU law status unresolved, complicating cross-border enforcement efforts.
Malta's government maintains that Bill 55 constitutes a legitimate public policy exception under EU recognition frameworks. Cassar argued that Malta's position reflects consistent policy predating EU membership and aligns with member state prerogatives recognized in EU law. An April 2026 ECJ ruling had affirmed that member states may initiate legal proceedings against operators failing to comply with gambling laws, though this decision did not directly address Bill 55.
A more promising avenue for definitive resolution emerged in October when Malta's Court of Appeal referred separate questions to the ECJ concerning Bill 55's compatibility with EU law. Legal observers anticipate this referral will address the substantive merits the previous case sidestepped. Hohenthanner predicted the ECJ would issue a definitive ruling on Bill 55 through this channel, potentially by 2027 or slightly later.
The Austrian Association for Betting and Gaming (OVWG) is monitoring developments closely, recognizing implications for member cross-border player claims. Until the Court of Appeal referral reaches conclusion, Bill 55 operates as functional law within Malta despite unresolved questions about its alignment with broader EU legal principles governing judicial cooperation and recognition of foreign judgements.
Source
iGaming BusinessRelated stories
PokerStars Exits New Zealand After Flutter Fails Licensing Eligibility
Trump's CFTC Nominees Dodge Clarity on Sports Betting Classification at Senate Hearing
43 State Attorneys General Challenge CFTC Authority Over Sports Event Contracts
UK Gambling Commission Declines to Regulate Pokemon Cards Despite Resale Value Concerns
More on CasinoAdvisor