CasinoAdvisor

Democratic Senators Demand CFTC Reverse Prediction Market Geofencing Directive

Casino Advisor
Written by
Last updated 5 hours ago | Fact checked |
Regulation · 2 min read
Democratic Senators Demand CFTC Reverse Prediction Market Geofencing Directive
Photo: GamblingNews

Based on reporting by GamblingNews →

A coalition of nine Democratic senators, led by California's Adam Schiff, has formally challenged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's recent policy shift on prediction market geofencing. In a letter sent to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, the lawmakers demanded the agency reverse its November 5 interpretation directing designated contract markets (DCMs) to stop restricting access to prediction market contracts based on geography.

The CFTC's directive effectively requires prediction market platforms to make their sports event contracts available across all 50 states and tribal lands, overriding existing court orders that prohibit such access in California, Michigan, Nevada, and Washington. The senators contend this unilateral federal action directly undermines state sovereignty and tribal gaming laws while potentially encouraging companies involved in active litigation to disregard jurisdictional restrictions.

The senators highlighted a September ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, which unanimously found that Kalshi's sports event contracts likely constituted unauthorized Class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act when offered on tribal lands. The court found the tribes had a strong likelihood of success in their claims against Kalshi and Polymarket. The letter's signatories questioned the timing of the CFTC's interpretation, issued just hours after the appeals court ruling, warning it sends a troubling signal to operators engaged in ongoing litigation.

Among the demands: the CFTC must withdraw the interpretation or suspend implementation pending resolution of all active court cases. The senators also requested preservation of all agency communications and records dating back to January 1, 2025, with confirmation of compliance by November 23.

CFTC Chairman Selig has shown no inclination to back down. During a CNBC interview, he asserted the agency believes it holds exclusive regulatory authority over prediction markets and is prepared to escalate the dispute to the Supreme Court if necessary. Selig also criticized states pursuing criminal cases against prediction market executives, arguing that companies operating under federal oversight should not face imprisonment threats over product classification disagreements.

Selig's comments followed Utah Attorney General Derek Brown's decision to file 14 criminal charges against Kalshi co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, including 13 felony counts alleging violations of state anti-gambling statutes. The coordination between state and federal enforcement efforts underscores the broader jurisdictional tensions defining the prediction market landscape.

This regulatory clash reflects deeper questions about whether prediction markets constitute financial derivatives subject to federal CFTC oversight or gambling products subject to state and tribal authority. The prediction market sector has experienced explosive growth, with operators like Polymarket generating substantial trading volume, yet this expansion has consistently triggered resistance from state regulators and tribal gaming authorities concerned about unauthorized gaming operations.

Related stories